Originals · Startup · Startups & Fintech
A UPI PIN alone does not prove a customer approved a payment, Telangana consumer commission tells SBI
The Nalgonda commission ordered SBI to repay Rs 55,000 lost in a 2022 UPI fraud, with interest, plus Rs 30,000 in compensation and costs.

A consumer commission in Telangana has held that the use of a UPI PIN does not, on its own, prove that the account holder approved a payment. The order was passed on 10 November 2026 by the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission at Nalgonda, presided over by Mamidi Christopher with members S. Sandhya Rani and K. Venkateshwarlu, in a complaint against State Bank of India. Some reports describe it as the state commission, but the order itself is from the Nalgonda district commission.
On 3 November 2022, Rs 55,000 was debited through UPI from a 44-year-old woman's savings account at SBI's Anneparthi branch. She said she had not made or authorised the payment and had not shared her credentials. She reported it on the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal on 6 November and gave a written complaint at the branch on 7 November, which SBI acknowledged that day. SBI argued that the payment had passed UPI PIN and mobile and SIM binding checks, so she must have authorised it or exposed her credentials, and that she had reported it late.
The commission rejected both arguments. Leaving out Sunday, 6 November, it treated 7 November as the third working day, which kept her inside the zero liability window in the RBI's 2017 circular on unauthorised electronic transactions, and it noted that the circular puts the burden of proving customer liability on the bank. "The mere fact that a UPI PIN or authentication mechanism was used does not, by itself, conclusively establish that the account holder personally authorised the transaction or that she was negligent," the order says. SBI's internal emails showed it had asked the beneficiary bank to place a hold, but nothing showed the money was recovered.
SBI has been told to pay the Rs 55,000 with 6% annual interest from 3 November 2022, plus Rs 20,000 in compensation and Rs 10,000 in costs, within 45 days. A separate claim against the cyber crime police was dismissed because filing a police complaint is not a service bought for a fee. The order can be appealed.
For UPI users, the PIN is the main thing standing between a fraudster and their account, and banks often point to it as proof of consent. This order says that is not enough without evidence. MediaNama notes that RBI's revised rules, which apply to transactions from 1 January 2027, will give customers five calendar days to report third party fraud.